An apparel brand came to me after years of Pinning. They had a Pinterest manager working behind the scenes, so from the front end, everything looked fine.
Then I started clicking their Pins.
Most of them sent shoppers to a collections page. A few went straight to the homepage. Almost none led to the product shown in the Pin.
Pinners don’t like this😡
Let me give you an example of what I mean…
A Pinner falls in love with a dress, clicks to learn more, and lands on a page with dozens of other dresses.
Now she has to scroll and search to find that perfect dress she saw in the Pin.
Most shoppers won’t bother.
If you’re learning how to sell products on Pinterest, start by checking where your Pins send people.
This one small linking mistake could be what’s standing between your traffic and your sales.
Hi Friends!
I’m Melissa, a Pinterest marketing strategist for eCommerce brands.
I help my clients get found, get seen, and drive consistent long-term traffic to their products and shop.
Where Do Your Pinterest Product Pins Link?
Take a minute and click on a few of your own Pins. Where do they take you?
If you land on your homepage or a collections page, you’re not alone.
This is one of the most common things I find when I audit an eCommerce Pinterest account.
And it happens to smart, hardworking brands all the time.
Why It’s So Easy to Fall Into This Trap
It’s not your fault. Here’s why so many brands end up here:
Instagram trained us. “Link in bio” taught a lot of us to send everyone to one place. Many social media managers bring that habit to Pinterest. But Pinterest isn’t Instagram. Every Pin can have its own link, and it should.
Finding the right URL takes time. When you’re Pinning lifestyle photos, you have to hunt down the exact product page for each one. Linking to a collection is sooo much faster. I get it. I’ve had to do this search myself for clients.
A collection feels “close enough.” It seems helpful to show shoppers more options. But a shopper who clicked on one dress wants that dress, not a page of fifty. Don’t get me wrong, collections have their place, and we’ll talk about when they’re the right choice.
Products sell out. Linking to a collection can feel safer than linking to a product that might go out of stock next month.
“Just drive traffic” advice. Most advice says to get people to your website, but it doesn’t say which page. Traffic that can’t find what it came for rarely buys.
Each of these makes sense in the moment. Together, they quietly cost you sales.
Linking is just one of the hidden Pinterest mistakes costing eCommerce stores customers. If you spotted one here, it’s worth checking for the others too.
The Good News? This Is an Easy Fix.
In this post, I’ll show you how to check where your Pins are sending shoppers and how to fix the ones that miss.
You’ll also learn when linking to a collection is actually the smart move, and how to handle products that sell out.
When your Pins take shoppers straight to the product they fell in love with, buying gets easier.
That means more of the traffic you already have turns into sales.
Ready? Let’s break it down.
Why the Wrong Pin Link Is Costing You Pinterest Sales
A link might seem like a tiny detail. But I’ve seen it quietly hold brands back in three big ways.
1. You Lose Shoppers Right When They’re Ready to Buy
People come to Pinterest to plan and shop.
When someone clicks a product Pin, she’s already interested. She wants to see the price, the sizes, and the “Add to Cart” button.
Send her to a collections page, and you’ve just given her a job.
Scroll…search…guess which one she saw😔
Every extra step is a chance for her to give up and go back to Pinterest.
When I audit a new account, one of the first things I do is click the top Pins to see if they lead to what they promise.
With the apparel brand I mentioned, most of their Pins didn’t.
They had years of beautiful Pins and real interest from Pinners. But the path from “I love that” to “I bought that” was broken.
2. Your Pins and Your Website Tell Two Different Stories
Pinterest wants to send people to helpful, relevant pages.
A Pin that shows one dress and leads to a page of fifty is a mismatch.
That makes for a frustrating experience for the Pinner.
Your Pins work best when the image, the description, and the page they lead to all match.
When they don’t, you’re making it harder for your content to do its job.
3. You Can’t See What’s Actually Working
When most of your Pins lead to the same few pages, you lose valuable information.
You can’t tell which products Pinterest shoppers are clicking on.
You can’t tell which Pins are leading to sales.
That makes it hard to plan.
Which products should you create more Pins for?
Which Pins are worth promoting with ads?
Without clear data, you’re guessing.
When I run Pinterest ads for clients, I promote the Pins that are already performing well organically.
That only works when I can see which products those Pins are driving people to.
So What Should You Do Instead?
The fix is simpler than you might think.
Next, I’ll walk you through how to check your Pins, fix the ones that miss, and know when a collection link is actually the right choice.
How to Sell More on Pinterest: The Pin-to-Product Path
The goal is simple.
Every Pin should take shoppers exactly where the Pin promises.
If a Pin shows a product, it leads to that product. If it shows a collection of ideas, it leads to a collection.
I call my process the Pin-to-Product Path.
It’s a five-step process I use with my clients to make sure every Pin has a clear path to purchase.
Step 1: Audit Where Your Pins Are Going
Start by clicking your own Pins. Open your top-performing Pins first, then scroll through your latest ones and click a few.
For each one, ask yourself:
Does this lead to the product shown in the Pin?
Can a shopper buy it in one or two clicks?
If products are tagged, do the tags lead to the right items?
This is the first thing I do with every new client account.
I look at the top Pins to see what resonates with Pinners and which Pinterest products are getting the most attention.
Then I click through to see if each Pin keeps its promise.
It’s a quick check, and it tells me a lot about where sales are slipping away.
Step 2: Match the Link to the Type of Pin
Not every Pin needs the same kind of link. Here’s how I decide:
Single product Pin → product page. One product in the Pin means one product page. No hunting required.
Collage or carousel Pin → collection page. When a Pin shows several products, a collection page makes sense. Shoppers can browse everything they saw in one place.
Lifestyle Pin with several items → tag the products. Product tags turn a lifestyle Pin into a shoppable Pin. If you’re wondering how to tag products on Pinterest, you can tag items from your product catalog when you create the Pin. Shoppers can then tap on the exact item they love, right from the Pin.
Bonus Tip: How Pinterest Rich Pins Affect Your Pin Description
Collection links come with a perk.
When a Pin links to a product page with Pinterest Rich Pins turned on, Pinterest pulls the description from your website.
With a collection page, your Pin description stays the way you wrote it.
That gives you more room to use the Pinterest keywords your shoppers are searching for.
Step 3: Build a Product Link Spreadsheet
Hunting down product URLs is the number one reason brands take the shortcut. It takes time.
Create a simple spreadsheet with every product name and its URL. When it’s time to Pin, you just copy and paste.
I do this for every client I work with.
Logging all products in one place is part of my setup process.
It saves hours later and keeps every Pin pointing to the right page.
Step 4: Have a Plan for Sold-Out Products
Products come and go. That’s normal for an online store.
When an item sells out, don’t leave the Pin pointing to a dead end. Update the link to a similar product or to the most relevant collection.
This keeps older Pins working for you, even after the product they first featured is gone.
Step 5: Screenshot Your Analytics Before You Make Changes
Before you update any links, take a screenshot of your Pin analytics: impressions, saves, Pin clicks, and outbound clicks. Then check again 30 to 60 days later.
I learned this one the hard way. I updated a client’s Pin link and its analytics reset. I wish I had captured the numbers first.
Now it’s part of my routine, so I can explain any dip and see exactly what changed.
Back to That Apparel Brand
When I started Pinning for the apparel brand, I made one rule. Every new product Pin links to the product shown. No shortcuts.
Yes, that meant searching their website for the right URL for each new lifestyle Pin.
It took more time.
Linking to a category would have been the easy way out, but that’s not how I roll.
I also started updating older Pins that sent shoppers to the wrong page.
Now, when a Pinner falls in love with a dress, one click takes her straight to that dress. She can see the price, choose her size, and add it to her cart.
How I Help You Do This Inside the Pinterest Jump Start
If reading this made you wonder how many of your Pins are missing the mark, the Pinterest Jump Start is a great place to start.
Inside the Jump Start, I audit your Pinterest account and check several of your product Pins to see where they’re sending shoppers.
You’ll know exactly what’s working, what needs fixing, and how to check the rest of your Pins using the Pin-to-Product Path.
From there, I build you a custom Pinterest strategy so every Pin works harder for your store.
It includes your keyword bank, board strategy, a 6-month content calendar, and more.
Plus, you get one free month of Pinterest management to see the strategy in action.
See everything included in the Pinterest Jump Start →
Imagine Every Pin Working for Your Store
When your Pins lead shoppers straight to what they want, everything gets easier.
Pinners who fall in love with your products can actually buy them.
The traffic you already have starts turning into sales. And you finally know which products Pinterest shoppers love most.
No more wondering if Pinterest is working. No more beautiful Pins that lead nowhere. Just a clear path from “I love that” to “I bought that.”
That’s a good feeling.
Pinterest Product Pin FAQs for eCommerce and Shopify Brands
“I have hundreds of old Pins. Do I really need to fix all of them?”
No. Start with the Pins that matter most. Look at your top-performing Pins first, since they’re getting the most attention. Then focus on Pins for products you still sell. Fix those, and you’ll cover most of your traffic. You can work through the rest over time.
“Will changing the link on an old Pin hurt its performance?”
Here’s what I’ve seen. When you change the URL on a Pin, its analytics start over. If it was one of your top performers, you’ll likely see a dip in the analytics after the change.
That’s exactly why Step 5 matters.
Screenshot your Pin’s analytics before you update the link. If the numbers drop afterward, you’ll know why. It’s not a sign that Pinterest stopped working for you, so don’t throw in the towel.
Related Read: “Pinterest Didn’t Work for Me”: Here’s What Actually Happened.
A temporary dip is worth it. A Pin with high impressions that sends shoppers to the wrong page isn’t doing much for your sales anyway.
“Isn’t a collection page better? Shoppers get to see more options.”
It depends on the Pin. If your Pin shows several products, like a collage or carousel, a collection page is a great choice. But if your Pin shows one product, the shopper wants that product. More options just get in the way.
“What about my catalog Pins?”
Good news. When you connect your product catalog, like through the Pinterest Shopify integration, Pinterest creates product Pins that link straight to each product page using your feed.
This mistake usually happens with the Pins you create yourself, like lifestyle photos, graphics, and seasonal Pins. Those are the ones to check.
Connected your catalog but still not seeing results? Read Your Pinterest Catalog Is Connected. So Why Aren’t Your Products Getting Found?
“What happens if I change a product’s URL on my website?”
Any Pin linked to the old URL will lead to an error page. This is a common reason Pinterest links stop working.
If you use Shopify and Pinterest together, check the box to create a URL redirect when you change a product’s URL. That way, older Pins still send shoppers to the right place.
“Someone else manages my Pinterest. How do I make sure they get this right?”
Share your product link spreadsheet with them and make it a clear rule: product Pins link to product pages. Then click a few of their new Pins each month to spot-check. It takes five minutes and keeps everyone on the same page.
Turn Pinterest Shopping Traffic Into Sales
So let’s recap…
Sending shoppers to your homepage or a collections page might feel close enough.
But when a Pinner clicks on a product she loves, she wants that product.
Every extra step is a chance for her to leave.
Here’s how to fix it with the Pin-to-Product Path:
Audit where your Pins are going. Click your top Pins and your latest ones.
Match the link to the type of Pin. Single products go to product pages. Collages and carousels go to collections.
Build a product link spreadsheet. No more hunting for URLs.
Have a plan for sold-out products. Keep older Pins working.
Screenshot your analytics before you make changes. So a dip never makes you give up.
You don’t have to fix everything today. Start with five of your top Pins. Click them. See where they lead. Then fix the ones that miss.
Small changes like this add up.
Every Pin you fix is one more open door to your store.
The Pinterest shopping traffic you’ve worked so hard to build gets a real chance to turn into sales. And you’ll finally know which products Pinterest shoppers love most.
Your Pins are already catching attention. Now let’s make sure they lead shoppers all the way to “Add to Cart.”
You’ve got this!
Ready for Pinterest to Bring You Sales, Not Just Pins?
You’ve put real work into your Pinterest account. Your Pins are catching attention. Now it’s time to make sure that attention turns into sales.
That’s what the Pinterest Jump Start is for.
I’ll audit your account and check around 25 of your product Pins to see exactly where they’re sending shoppers.
Then I’ll build you a custom Pinterest strategy designed for your store, your products, and your shoppers.
Within 30 days, you’ll have a clear plan to:
✅ Fix the Pins that are costing you sales
✅ Get found by shoppers searching for products like yours
✅ Know exactly what to Pin for the next 6 months
✅ Track the numbers that actually matter
Plus, you get one free month of Pinterest management, so you can see your new strategy in action without lifting a finger.
No more guessing. No more beautiful Pins that lead nowhere. Just a Pinterest account that works as hard as you do.
Get Your Pinterest Jump Start →
Fill out the quick contact form, and we’ll set up a call to talk about your store and your goals. I can’t wait to help your Pins lead shoppers all the way to checkout.
More from the blog.
