The Hidden Pinterest Mistakes Costing Your eCommerce Store Customers (Why Your Strategy Isn’t Working and How to Fix It)
You’ve likely heard the buzz that Pinterest is a powerhouse for driving eCommerce traffic, so you handed the keys to your trusted Social Media Manager, expecting a flood of new buyers.
But instead of sales, you’re seeing crickets. Maybe even a report from your SMM claiming, “Pinterest just doesn't work for your brand.”
It’s incredibly confusing and frustrating to watch a platform with so much potential fall flat while you’re left wondering where the disconnect lies. The reality is that Pinterest isn’t broken; the strategy is.
Most eCommerce brands and uneducated social media managers treat Pinterest like a social media platform, but it’s actually a visual search engine. Without a specialized optimization strategy, your products remain invisible to the people actively looking for them.
Hi Friends!
I’m Melissa, a Pinterest marketing strategist for eCommerce brands.
I help my clients get found, get seen, and drive consistent long-term traffic to their products and shop.
With over 600 million monthly active users, understanding how to leverage Pinterest can be the key to driving consistent traffic to your website and avoiding being overlooked in search results.
If you are struggling to drive consistent traffic and sales to your eCommerce store, you have come to the right place. In this blog post, we’ll explore actionable strategies to improve your traffic and visibility. Let’s dive in and transform your eCommerce game!
How Pinterest Frustration Shows Up in Your Business
When your Pinterest marketing strategy isn’t working, the effects ripple through your entire business.
It’s not just about low engagement numbers; it has real-world consequences that can hinder your growth and add to your daily stress.
Here are a few ways this problem shows up for eCommerce brands and small businesses:
Missed Opportunities: Every day your catalog isn't connected, your product listings aren’t optimized with Pinterest SEO, and your boards have no description, it's another day your ideal customer finds your competitor instead😔.
You’re missing out on a direct line to an audience of Pinterest users actively searching for solutions and new products like yours, leading to lost sales and slower growth.
Frustration with Your SMM: You hired a Social Media Manager to handle your social media marketing, and while those platforms are growing, they report that “Pinterest just doesn’t work.”
This creates a difficult situation where you feel let down and question their expertise. They may be applying common mistakes and the wrong strategies to a powerful tool they don’t fully understand.
Reliance on Expensive Alternatives: To compensate for the lack of organic Pinterest traffic, you find yourself forced to spend more on Meta and TikTok ads, other paid marketing strategies, or even paying for user-generated content (UGC).
This increases your customer acquisition cost and strains your marketing budget, all while a great way to reach new audiences for free remains untapped.
Here’s the Reality: Pinterest Is In a League of Its Own
If you’re feeling this way, you’re not alone.
Pinterest is its own beast.
It is one of the most misunderstood marketing platforms.
The main issue is that most business owners and even many social media marketers have been taught to treat it like Instagram or Facebook.
They don’t know.
They think it’s just another social media platform and focus on getting likes and posting daily content designed for immediate engagement, like dancing while making a smoothie, or lip-syncing to the latest trending song.
These are all things that make sense on other social media platforms.
But Pinterest isn’t just another social media platform; it’s a visual search engine. Pinterest users come for visual searches, product discovery, and inspiration, not so much social interaction.
Success on Pinterest isn’t about social interaction, but about search engine optimization, having a solid board and image strategy, along with staying on top of Trends before they hit.
When your strategy is built around followers rather than the Pinterest algorithm or Pinterest SEO, you’re making it nearly impossible for your target audience to discover your products, content, and even your Pinterest profile.
The issue isn’t with you or your business; it’s about having the right expertise to optimize your profile for driving traffic.
To do this effectively, eCommerce brands should:
Connect their catalog to ensure products update in real time.
Set up and use the Pinterest Tag.
Check eligibility for the Verified Merchant Program.
By implementing these strategies, your eCommerce business can leverage Pinterest as a powerful tool to drive traffic, increase visibility, and boost conversions.
Imagine What's Possible With a Real Pinterest Strategy
When you solve this problem, everything changes. Your Pinterest business account transforms into a reliable source of consistent traffic and brand awareness. You’ll see a steady stream of interested buyers who are actively looking for the products you sell, prepared to purchase for the first time or become repeat customers.
With a specialized Pinterest algorithm strategy, your product Pins will start appearing in search results and expanding your reach to new audiences every day.
The frustration fades, replaced by confidence and relief. You’ll finally see long-term results and a higher conversion rate, knowing your Pinterest marketing strategy is working.
Your eCommerce brand will grow. You’ll discover new ways to reach your ideal client, boost your business account, and establish Pinterest as a powerful marketing tool in your overall strategy.
3 Strategies to Turn Pinterest Into a Traffic-Driving Machine
Ready for your next step?
Here are three effective strategies that will unlock Pinterest’s true potential for your eCommerce or small business.
1. Master the Platform with Pinterest-Specific Education
The first thing you need is understanding. Pinterest operates very differently from other social media platforms, so investing in a course tailored to Pinterest marketing strategies will save you a lot of time and frustration.
A solid Pinterest course teaches platform-specific best practices, how the Pinterest algorithm works, a pin design strategy for eCommerce, and the fundamentals of Pinterest SEO.
Who do I recommend?
Heather Farris!!!
She is a verified Pinterest Educator and runs an affordable academy where she shares all her Pinterest knowledge. There are live Q&A calls almost every week, so you can ask her your pressing Pinterest questions.
Want a 1:1 strategy session to help you navigate a confusing Pinterest problem? These are also included in the Pin Profit Academy.
Why does educating yourself or your SMM work?
Pinterest users don’t scroll on Pinterest to be entertained as they do on other platforms. They are there to do, buy, and try.
The Pinterest customer journey often begins with discovery, where users search for inspiration or solutions to their needs. By creating Pins tailored to all stages of the sales funnel, from awareness and consideration to decision-making, you can ensure your content reaches potential customers at the perfect moment to drive action.
Understanding how Pinterest users search, you can create content that guides them through every stage of their buying journey, leading to long-term results.
Not ready to dive in yourself?
Have your Social Media Manager take the training so they’re equipped to use Pinterest as a visual search engine, not just another social network.
2. Set Your Pinterest Account Up for Success With a Full Audit and Optimization
Before you can start driving traffic, you need a fully optimized Pinterest account. This means auditing your business account to get it on the path to success.
Everything starts with a solid foundation, and your Pinterest account is no different.
To make this process simple, I offer a Pinterest Jump Start service.
This is a complete audit and optimization for your Pinterest business account.
My Pinterest Jump Start package starts with a call to learn about your business, your Pinterest goals, and any specific areas you want to focus on. From there, I do a full audit of your account, covering everything from profile optimization to board titles and descriptions.
Once the audit is complete, I provide a detailed report with actionable steps for optimizing your account. This includes keywords for your profile and boards, suggested board topics, and tips for creating visually appealing pins.
Next, we will have another call to discuss the report and go over any questions or concerns you may have. I can also provide feedback on your new profile updates and answer any questions about Pinterest best practices.
But it doesn't stop there.
The Pinterest Jump Start package also includes a one-month content calendar customized for your business. This will help guide your content creation and ensure you are consistently posting high-quality Pins that align with your business goals.
In addition, I offer ongoing support and guidance throughout the month via email or messaging to answer any additional questions or provide further recommendations.
Are you ready to take the guesswork out of your Pinterest strategy and start creating content that drives consistent traffic to your eCommerce store?
This is a great way to give your Social Media Manager or marketing team everything they need to run your Pinterest account effectively.
3. Supercharge Your Strategy by Hiring a Pinterest Expert
Sometimes, the hardest part is taking action when you’re not sure what works. That’s why many eCommerce brands and small businesses choose to hire an expert.
A skilled Pinterest account manager provides:
In-depth knowledge of the Pinterest algorithm
Best practices for creating optimized pins
Scheduling for new products
Management of effective Pinterest ads
Expertise in leveraging every marketing tool on the platform
Why is this so effective?
It eliminates common mistakes, saves you a lot of time, and ensures your Pinterest content consistently drives traffic, grows your audience, and boosts brand awareness.
You benefit from current marketing strategies that keep up with Pinterest's algorithm updates and trends, delivering long-term results.
My Pinterest Account Management service takes care of everything, so you’re free to focus on other areas of your business. From pin image creation to search engine optimization, from writing pin descriptions to measuring analytics, I optimize every detail so your Pinterest boards become a winning channel for your eCommerce brand’s growth.
Answering Your Lingering Pinterest Questions
Still wondering if Pinterest is a good fit for your business or if you’ll need a lot of time to start seeing results? Here are answers to some of the following questions I hear most from small businesses and eCommerce brands:
"Why should I invest in Pinterest when other platforms seem more popular?"
Pinterest isn’t just another social media platform; it’s a visual search engine with millions of monthly active users who come specifically to find and plan new ideas and purchases.
Unlike standard social media marketing, where content disappears fast, a high-quality, optimized pin can appear in search results and drive Pinterest traffic for months or even years, delivering steady conversion rates and brand awareness.
"I’ve tried Pinterest before, and it didn’t work for me. Why would it work now?"
Most brands don’t see results because common mistakes like neglecting Pinterest SEO, not using keyword-rich pin descriptions, or choosing the wrong board titles keep their Pinterest pins invisible to their target audience.
The good news is that with the right marketing strategies and best practices, anyone can start using Pinterest as a powerful tool to reach new audiences, launch new products, and drive eCommerce traffic every single day.
It’s Time to Unlock Your Pinterest Potential
Your business doesn’t have to settle for disappointing Pinterest results.
By understanding how this unique marketing channel works, you’ll open the doors to consistent traffic, new audiences, and lasting brand growth.
Tired of feeling stuck with Pinterest? Let me take it off your plate
If you're wondering why your Pinterest efforts aren't translating into sales or website traffic, you're not alone. Many eCommerce brands struggle to connect their pinning strategy to actual business goals, leaving them with plenty of pretty boards but no measurable return on investment.
But when someone else handles it correctly, everything changes.
When you hire me to manage your Pinterest account (or get started with my Pinterest Jump Start offer), you’ll:
✅ Stop wasting hours trying to figure out the Pinterest algorithm yourself
✅ Get a fully optimized account, strategic pin image creation, and keyword-rich pin descriptions that actually drive Pinterest traffic
✅ Finally have time to focus on scaling your business, launching new products, or connecting with your ideal clients
It’s time to step off the Pinterest hamster wheel. Let’s create a smarter, more sustainable strategy that drives real results for your business.
Sign up for my newsletter (right here), where I often share Pinterest tips, tricks, and of course, awesome freebies. You will receive emails every Wednesday, mainly focused on Pinterest marketing for online shops and how we can get Pinterest working for you.
Book a FREE discovery call (right here), and we can discuss whether Pinterest marketing would be a good fit for your eCommerce or online shop.
More from the blog.
